Who are we?

Most Americans over the age of 20 can recall Roger Daughtry’s Daltry (lead singer for The Who) searing voice as he wailed, “Who are you?” Who Are You is also the theme music for the very popular drama CSI. As we look back over the first nine months of Barack Obama’s presidency, I think it is important for us, as Americans, to try to come to grips with who we are.

Thirty years ago, I think the answer was obvious. We were the good guys. We just elected a new president, Ronald Reagan. If we didn’t know that we were the good guys, he was more than happy to tell us. Those other guys, the Russians, they were the bad guys. We were honest, law-abiding citizens. More importantly, there was a collective America. Everyone seemed to want to share the responsibility of making America better. From the janitor pushing a broom to the CEO in an Armani suit, we were all working to make America better.

Something changed. The change probably started in the late ’60s and early ’70s, but it began to be really easily noticed in the late ’80s. We stopped working for us and began working for ourselves. This can best be seen by looking at our major corporations. Our major corporations throughout the ’60s and ’70s were good corporate citizens. It was unheard of at the time for a corporation to move its operation overseas and shut down plants here in the United States. That just wasn’t done. Corporations paid a fair wage. In return, Americans bought American products. Everyone profited.

annual wage growth, by group, 1973-2006 epi

click on image for larger version

Over the next 30 years, CEO wages skyrocketed. Corporate profits ballooned to unimaginable levels. The Dow Jones industrial averages doubled, tripled, quintupled and more in a short period of time (see chart below). The investment crowd made billions of dollars, yet wages stagnated (see chart above). Corporations moved overseas in search of cheaper labor and friendlier environmental laws. Small towns withered on the vine. Huge sections of large cities like Detroit, St. Louis and Baltimore became ghost towns. One income was not good enough to keep the family afloat. Now we needed two incomes. Even with two full-time working parents, household budgets are still strained.

djia 1976-2009

click on image for larger version (From Morningstar)

After the economic collapse which started almost exactly a year ago, there is talk in Washington about new regulations. We also need to talk about who we are. How should our corporations act? Should they act in the best interest of their stockholders? Should these large corporations act in the best interests of America? Sometimes the two interests are not the same. Shouldn’t we expect corporations who hire hundreds of thousands of Americans to act in our best interest? We, as Americans, created an environment which made these corporations successful. Samantha Stevens, the beautifully seductive witch from Bewitched, did not twinkle her nose to get us into this predicament. Instead, hard-working Americans helped these corporations meet and exceed their goals. So, should we expect something in return… something more than just a job?

I expect good corporate citizenship. We all should expect good corporate citizenship. There’s a reason why General Motors, IBM, Dow Chemicals and other Fortune 500 companies did not arise in China, Mexico or Dubai. They arose here in the United States because we created an atmosphere that was friendly to business. Now we need Congress to restore some of the balance that was lost over the last 30 years. Corporations need to be taxed for sending things out of the country and having them processed and then transporting them back here for sale. These taxes need to make it prohibitively expensive to ship jobs out of the United States. Secondly, corporations are not people. Congress needs to pass a law stating that the rights of people should always usurp the rights of corporations (this would seem obvious but is, amazingly, hugely controversial in the Courts). Thirdly, Congress needs to pass health care reform that truly fixes the way healthcare is delivered in the United States. Finally, Congress needs to pass the Employee Free Choice Act. This makes it easier for people to unionize. If we can get Congress to do this once and for all, we then create jobs. We actually create better paying jobs and a better lifestyle for all of us. Only then can I answer the question of who we are. We are the same as we’ve always been, a country of the people, for the people and by the people.

  • YJoseph
    Corporations have a charter that is apporved by the state in which they incorporate and may be revoked by that state. In effect, "We the People" can have a say in what constitutes appropriate behaviors of corporations towards the common good.

    (Notice I did not use the phrase corporate citizenship. That is because citizenship implies personhood and coprorations are limited liability organizations whose charters can be revoked while adult citizens of sound mind are fully liable for their actions.)

    Why do we not campaign to revoke their charters when they do harm to our communities?
  • YJoseph
    Corporations have a charter that is apporved by the state in which they incorporate and may be revoked by that state. In effect, "We the People" can have a say in what constitutes appropriate behaviors of corporations towards  the common good.

    (Notice I did not use the phrase corporate citizenship. That is because citizenship implies personhood and coprorations are limited liability organizations whose charters can be revoked while adult citizens of sound mind are fully liable for their actions.)

    Why do we not campaign to revoke their charters when they do harm to our communities?
  • ecthompson
    in the game of government, it is never too late.

    I argee 100%. Now, the question is how do we get this done?
  • ecthompson
    in the game of government, it is never too late.

    I argee 100%. Now, the question is how do we get this done?
  • ecthompson
    Alan8 -

    Thanks for your thoughtful comments. I'm not sure that I disagree as a matter fact, I think you're exactly right. We look at the economic crisis we see that Congress change the rules which allow banks and other financial institutions to take greater risks with our money. Both Democrats and Republicans supported this legislation. I also agree that this is not a horse race. On the other hand, I want to vote for somebody who can influence policy. In Arianna Huffington's book, Fanatics and Fools, she talks about her journey from being a Republican to being an independent to being a Democrat. For the most part, I agree with her. They're things that I like that are Republican themes like smaller government and more efficient use of our tax money. They're things that I like about being a Democrat like standing up for the average American and that it's not all about me.

    To get things done in Washington, you need to have a coalition of people working together. Until the Green party develops critical mass, they are not gonna be able to get anything done. I want to decrease the influence of corporations on the government. I want to clean up Wall Street. I want to decrease the military footprint. I want to increase spending on education, healthcare and infrastructure. I think... I hope, with hard work, those like-minded Democrats can beat the other ones into submission.

    Again, I appreciate your thoughts.
  • ecthompson
    Alan8 -

    Thanks for your thoughtful comments. I'm not sure that I disagree as a matter fact, I think you're exactly right. We look at the economic crisis we see that Congress change the rules which allow banks and other financial institutions to take greater risks with our money. Both Democrats and Republicans supported this legislation. I also agree that this is not a horse race. On the other hand, I want to vote for somebody who can influence policy. In Arianna Huffington's book, Fanatics and Fools, she talks about her journey from being a Republican to being an independent to being a Democrat. For the most part, I agree with her. They're things that I like that are Republican themes like smaller government and more efficient use of our tax money. They're things that I like about being a Democrat like standing up for the average American and that it's not all about me.

    To get things done in Washington, you need to have a coalition of people working together. Until the Green party develops critical mass, they are not gonna be able to get anything done. I want to decrease the influence of corporations on the government. I want to clean up Wall Street. I want to decrease the military footprint. I want to increase spending on education, healthcare and infrastructure. I think... I hope, with hard work, those like-minded Democrats can beat the other ones into submission.

    Again, I appreciate your thoughts.
  • Alan8
    Great objectives. Unfortunately the two largest political parties are on the take.

    They're so brazen, they do it right out in the open. Max Baucus accepted over 3 million dollars from insurance corporations, and voted against a public option. THIS USED TO BE CALLED BRIBARY, AND IS A CRIME!

    The solution: Replace these corrupt parties with the Green Party, which doesn't accept ANY corporate money, and represents CITIZENS' interests.

    Change won't happen overnight, but by continuing to vote for the corporate parties, you guarantee the corruption will continue.

    Yes, when you vote Green, your candidate will probably lose. But it's an ELECTION not a HORSE RACE! Your losing vote will send a message to the corporate parties WHY they're losing your vote. Your losing vote will encourage others to vote Green. Finally, your losing vote will enable the Green Party to receive matching Federal funds if they get a mere 5% of the vote.

    Pretty good for a "losing" vote. Better than you'd do with a losing ticket at the race track.

    VOTE GREEN!
  • Alan8
    Great objectives.  Unfortunately the two largest political parties are on the take.

    They're so brazen, they do it right out in the open.  Max Baucus accepted over 3 million dollars from insurance corporations, and voted against a public option.  THIS USED TO BE CALLED BRIBARY, AND IS A CRIME!

    The solution: Replace these corrupt parties with the Green Party, which doesn't accept ANY corporate money, and represents CITIZENS' interests.

    Change won't happen overnight, but by continuing to vote for the corporate parties, you guarantee the corruption will continue.

    Yes, when you vote Green, your candidate will probably lose.  But it's an ELECTION not a HORSE RACE!  Your losing vote will send a message to the corporate parties WHY they're losing your vote.  Your losing vote will encourage others to vote Green.  Finally, your losing vote will enable the Green Party to receive matching Federal funds if they get a mere 5% of the vote.

    Pretty good for a "losing" vote.  Better than you'd do with a losing ticket at the race track.

    VOTE GREEN!
  • MrBadExample
    It may well be too late to change the game, but Congress could go after the off-shore havens' tax status. A really interesting tax on trades in derivatives should follow, since the wall street shenanigans are what's put us so deeply in the hole. I think the biggest piece has to be a change of attitude. So many of my educated white collar friends went 'tsk tsk' when the UAW jobs started going away. Now it's architects and engineers who compete with India. The corporate guys are coming to stick it to everyone, so a little solidarity among the workers is long past due.
  • MrBadExample
    It may well be too late to change the game, but Congress could go after the off-shore havens' tax status. A really interesting tax on trades in derivatives should follow, since the wall street shenanigans are what's put us so deeply in the hole. I think the biggest piece has to be a change of attitude. So many of my educated white collar friends went 'tsk tsk' when the UAW jobs started going away. Now it's architects and engineers who compete with India. The corporate guys are coming to stick it to everyone, so a little solidarity among the workers is long past due.
  • ugg boots uk sale
    http://www.hotuggsale.co.uk
    Many more woman are now starting to wear Ugg Boots,
    which over the last couple of years seem to have become the must have accessory.
  • ecthompson
    I suspect that you will see a renewed effort to reign in corporations after the healthcare reform passes.

    Thanks for your comments.
  • ecthompson
    I suspect that you will see a renewed effort to reign in corporations after the healthcare reform passes.

    Thanks for your comments.
  • Guest
    Obama promised to try and make the corporation pay more thatmove the jobs overseas. I want to know how the republicans will defend the rights of the corporations to do this. This particular item was part of my deep desire for him to get elected. How can working americans justify them not getting taxed to the hilt.... I hope in the next 3-1/2 years he can get this done. Everyone wants him to do things immediately but it all takes longer than 9 months.
  • Guest
    Obama promised to try and make the corporation pay more that move the jobs overseas. I want to know how the republicans will defend the rights of the corporations to do this. This particular item was part of my deep desire for him to get elected. How can working americans justify them not getting taxed to the hilt.... I hope in the next 3-1/2 years he can get this done. Everyone wants him to do things immediately but it all takes longer than 9 months.
  • ecthompson
    you are correct. I fixed it. Thanks.
  • ecthompson
    you are correct. I fixed it. Thanks.
  • Jonathan
    It's Roger Daltry, not Daughtry.
  • Jonathan
    It's Roger Daltry, not Daughtry.
blog comments powered by Disqus