Much ado about emotional feelings

Some words of wisdom from someone who lost his wife in the 9/11 attacks.

I remember taking calculus as a senior in high school. I would like to say that it was all Greek to me, but I think that Greek would be much easier to understand. I simply didn’t get it. Calculus did not resemble any of the math I had learned up until that point. In spite of the fact that it used some algebra and geometry and elementary functions, I was drowning in the abstract concepts.

The “controversy” over this mosque is hitting me the same way. I don’t get it. Al Qaeda brought down the Twin Towers and Al Qaeda is a radial offshoot of the Islamic faith. Therefore, a mosque should not be built within two blocks of the Ground Zero? Really? I understand that emotions are running high. All Americans feel an emotional attachment to the Twin Towers, Ground Zero and 9/11. For several months in late 2001, we were all New Yorkers. Everyone was glued to their TVs.

Policy should not be made based on emotional feelings. Policy should be made based on sound fundamental principles. We can find many of those principles within our Constitution. We know that our forefathers fled Europe in order to practice religion the way they wanted to practice it. Because religious freedom is important to all Americans, it is written into our constitution. The Constitution clearly says — freedom of religion. We also have the right to own property. So a religious group would like to place a religious structure on private land. What’s the big deal?

I’ve been told that various factions both inside and outside of New York don’t think that building a mosque that close to Ground Zero is a good idea. So? Unless the mosque is going to be built with federal, state or local funds, it is a private enterprise. To my way of thinking, if you really don’t want a mosque there, then you need to buy the property. Maybe you should ask Rupert Murdoch to lend you the money.

I’ve also been told that Hamas supports building a mosque. I don’t care what Hamas thinks. They are terrorist organization that does not influence policy here in the United States. We should follow our rules and our laws. (Oh, and Governor Paterson should stay out of this. Nothing good can come from jumping in the middle of this insanity. Howard Dean, what happened?!?!? Did you get hit on the head? Can we revoke his liberal license?)

Finally, how close to Ground Zero can you build a mosque without this controversy? If two blocks is too close, how ’bout five blocks? If five blocks is too close, how about 10 blocks? Where is the line? Should we put it to a vote? I find this whole controversy a complete and total distraction from the important issues that grip our country. We need jobs. Those of us who have jobs need a living wage. We need clean energy. We need the economy to get better. We need to bring our troops home from two ineffectual wars. Yet, here we are, fixated on a mosque being built on private land two blocks from Ground Zero. This whole argument makes just as much sense as calculus did back in high school.

BTW, I’ll be on Local Edge Radio at 4 pm EST, today! Check me out.

  • Joe White

    This is much more than a mosque, in case you weren't aware. The mosque is only a small part of this facility. There's a whole lot more than prayer that is planned in this place.

    Don't care what Hamas thinks? You should.

    It's important to know what one's enemies are up to, don't you think?

  • http://www.whereistheoutrage.net/wordpress/about/ EC Thompson, MD

    I do agree to keep your enemies close. There is no doubt about that. But I'm not going to let my enemies dictate my behavior.

  • margaret

    When Timothy McVeigh bombed the Oklahoma City building did anyone ask what religion he belonged too? I don't even know which if any he belonged too. Know if he was to be a catholic and he said he did the bombing to protest say for instance the governments ban on not allowing guns in the state. Something stupid… Would you have an objection to a catholic church being next to the site? This complex is trying to being people together with a community center so people can learn about the religion. The owners have owned this property for years and are trying to welcome people to understand what most muslims believe,. Living in harmony with your fellow man…
    I mean this is so nuts it is like forbidding a catholic priest to live next to a school just because of all the child abuse that they found was going on. I know Joe is going to tell me I am nuts. But this country is a mixture of all people. Maybe you are right they need to buy the land and put up something there. Otherwise I see the place unfortunately being vandalized by idiots…

  • Joe White

    What nonsense.

    Hamas wants you to allow the project to go forward.

    If you are not in favor of allowing it to go forward, have they dictated your behavior?

    There's a lot of good reasons to look at if and why this project should be allowed to go forward. Possible involvement and support from a terrorist organization would be at the top of the list.

  • Carramken

    I like what William Saletan had to say,
    “This was never a war between us and the Muslim world. It's a war between us and al-Qaida. The central battleground in this war isn't Iraq, Afghanistan, or Lower Manhattan. It's Islam. That's the ground al-Qaida is fighting for. It's the ground Imam Rauf wants to take back. He wants to build an Islam that loves America, embraces freedom, and preaches coexistence. Let's help him.”

  • Scott…

    So if this ground is so hallowed why are we building a skyscraper there, meaning an office builing…this IS all a distraction…

  • margaret

    From what they were saying on NPR this morning. The group has the money and bought the building for the community center but the other group HAS NOT bought the building to build the mosque and DOES NOT have the money to do so.So maybe someone ought to buy the building first to keep it from happening. So like Scott says it is not worth the news media attention

  • Pingback: Coping With the Death of your Dog | Taking care of your pet